Changes to UK packaging waste charges are exposing tensions between environmental policy and industrial competitiveness, as glass producers secure relief while metal packaging manufacturers warn of growing cost disadvantages.
The UK’s extended producer responsibility (EPR) system is facing scrutiny over how packaging waste fees affect material choices, domestic manufacturing and investment. Government intervention to reduce charges on glass packaging has addressed concerns in the hospitality sector but prompted warnings that the changes could place greater pressure on other materials.
Discover B2B Marketing That Performs
Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.
The dispute highlights a challenge for packaging policymakers: ensuring that environmental charges encourage recycling without creating unintended commercial advantages for particular packaging formats.
For manufacturers, the issue extends beyond the accuracy of EPR reporting and compliance. The way fees are calculated and distributed can influence packaging design, material selection and long-term production decisions.
How packaging weight affects EPR costs
Under the UK’s packaging EPR system, producers contribute towards the cost of managing household packaging waste. Charges depend on the type and weight of packaging placed on the market.
For the 2025–26 assessment year, base fees were set at £192 per tonne for glass, £259 for steel, £423 for plastic and £461 for fibre-based composite packaging.
However, these rates do not directly indicate the cost of an individual container or the overall environmental performance of a material.
A heavy glass bottle or steel food can can attract a higher EPR charge per unit than a lighter alternative, even when the alternative has a higher fee per tonne.
This difference has raised concerns among manufacturers that weight-based fees could encourage businesses to change packaging materials primarily to reduce costs.
The Metal Packaging Manufacturers Association (MPMA) argues that the current structure makes steel food cans less commercially competitive than some plastic and fibre-based composite alternatives.
The association maintains that these differences risk encouraging material switching without necessarily delivering better environmental outcomes.
The concern reflects a broader limitation of weight-based charging. Although packaging weight helps determine waste management costs, it does not capture every aspect of a material’s environmental performance.
Glass packaging reforms raise questions over cost allocation
Glass packaging has become a prominent example of the challenges involved in distributing EPR costs.
The material’s weight has created significant charges for some drinks producers, particularly those supplying beer, wine and spirits in glass bottles.
A separate problem emerged over glass drinks containers supplied directly to pubs, restaurants and other licensed hospitality venues.
Some of these containers were subject to household packaging EPR charges despite entering commercial waste collection systems. This created the potential for businesses to face producer responsibility charges alongside commercial waste collection costs for the same packaging.
In November 2026, the UK Government announced changes to address the issue.
From April 2027, glass drinks containers supplied directly by producers to licensed hospitality venues will no longer be liable for the relevant EPR disposal fees.
The government estimates that the changes could reduce charges by up to 6p per beer bottle and 10p per wine bottle. Based on its example of a pub selling 10,000 beer bottles and 3,700 wine bottles annually, the potential saving could reach £870.
However, the immediate financial benefit would go to businesses responsible for paying the EPR fees, such as drinks manufacturers. Any savings passed on to hospitality operators would depend on commercial arrangements.
The government has also proposed stronger fee discounts for highly recyclable packaging.
Indicative estimates suggest that fees for packaging classified as highly recyclable could fall by around 30–40% in 2027–28 and 2028–29 compared with the existing approach. The proposals remain subject to consultation, and the eventual reductions will depend on packaging volumes and waste management costs.
The measures are intended to make the system fairer and strengthen incentives for recyclable packaging. However, they have also prompted concerns about how changes affecting one material could influence charges elsewhere.
Metal packaging industry warns of competitive disadvantages
The UK’s metal packaging industry has questioned whether the glass reforms could create further imbalances.
In November 2026, the MPMA published a manifesto calling for closer coordination between environmental regulation, trade policy and industrial strategy.
The association represents manufacturers of steel and aluminium cans, closures and related packaging for food, beverages and household products.
It says the sector contributes more than £4bn to the UK economy and supports over 4,000 skilled jobs.
A central concern is the effect of EPR charges on steel food cans, which the association says already face higher costs per container than some competing packaging formats.
Responding to the government’s glass announcement, MPMA chief executive Jason Galley warned that removing charges from glass would not eliminate the underlying waste management costs.
Instead, the association argues, those costs could be redistributed across other packaging materials, increasing the disadvantage faced by steel containers.
The MPMA has also questioned whether proposed changes to recyclability-based fees will sufficiently address differences between materials.
These concerns represent the industry’s assessment of potential consequences rather than confirmed outcomes of the reforms.
Nevertheless, they raise an important question about the design of EPR systems: whether correcting a cost imbalance for one packaging material could create new pressures for another.
Trade and industrial policies add to manufacturing pressures
The MPMA’s concerns extend beyond packaging waste charges.
Manufacturers also face energy costs, raw material prices, trade measures and other environmental regulations. These factors can influence production costs, investment decisions and competition with imported products.
In its November 2026 policy statement, the MPMA warned that environmental, trade and industrial policies were being developed without sufficient consideration of their combined effects.
Its recommendations include maintaining tariff-free import quotas for packaging steel, supporting demand for UK-produced steel and recycled metals, and extending the UK’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) to cover filled steel and aluminium packaging.
CBAM is designed to address differences in carbon costs between domestic production and certain imported goods.
The association argues that excluding relevant finished products could disadvantage UK manufacturers competing with overseas suppliers.
These concerns are distinct from the application of packaging EPR itself. Imported and domestically produced packaging can both fall within the UK’s producer responsibility requirements.
However, equivalent EPR obligations do not necessarily mean that manufacturers face comparable energy, trade or production costs.
For policymakers, the challenge is to assess how these measures interact rather than treating each regulation as a separate issue.
A policy designed to improve environmental performance may achieve its immediate objective while creating commercial pressures elsewhere in the supply chain.
Recyclability does not tell the whole environmental story
The UK is introducing a more differentiated approach to packaging fees through its Recyclability Assessment Methodology (RAM).
The methodology classifies applicable packaging as green, amber or red according to its recyclability within existing collection, sorting and reprocessing systems.
Green-rated packaging is considered more recyclable, while amber and red classifications indicate increasing barriers to effective recycling.
These classifications influence EPR fees, creating financial incentives for businesses to use packaging that is easier to recycle.
The approach is intended to encourage better packaging design and reduce the use of formats that are difficult to process.
However, recyclability is not the same as overall environmental performance.
The environmental impact of packaging can also depend on raw material production, manufacturing energy, transport, product protection, reuse and the effectiveness of waste collection systems.
A lighter container is not automatically the more sustainable choice. Equally, a recyclable material may deliver fewer environmental benefits where collection and processing infrastructure is limited.
Food packaging illustrates this complexity.
Metal cans can preserve food for long periods without refrigeration before opening, helping maintain product quality and reduce spoilage during storage and distribution.
These benefits need to be considered alongside the environmental costs of producing, transporting and recycling the containers.
This does not weaken the case for rewarding recyclability. It highlights the importance of understanding what EPR fees measure and which environmental outcomes they are intended to influence.
Domestic production and supply chain resilience
The debate also raises questions about the resilience of domestic manufacturing and food supply chains.
Metal packaging is widely used for vegetables, fish, meat, soups and prepared foods. Its durability and ability to preserve products for extended periods make it an established part of food production and distribution.
The MPMA argues that weakening domestic can manufacturing could increase dependence on imported packaging and reduce the UK’s capacity to produce essential food containers.
The association has linked these concerns to food security, emergency preparedness and national resilience.
There is no established evidence that EPR fees have already caused widespread closures of UK can manufacturing facilities or shortages of packaged food.
However, the industry’s warnings draw attention to the relationship between packaging production and the wider manufacturing economy.
Packaging costs can affect procurement decisions, production planning and investment across several connected industries.
Changing from one packaging material to another may also require new equipment, revised product specifications and adjustments to storage or distribution systems.
For manufacturers making long-term investments, predictable regulation is therefore important.
Uncertainty over future charges can complicate decisions about production capacity, machinery and material sourcing.
What the changes mean for packaging businesses
For packaging manufacturers, brand owners and food and drink producers, the debate reinforces the need to assess packaging costs in a wider commercial and environmental context.
Comparing published EPR fees per tonne is not enough to establish the cost of different packaging formats.
Businesses need to consider the charge per individual package, the material’s recyclability classification and its suitability for the product.
Product protection, shelf life, transport requirements and the availability of alternative materials can also influence the overall cost of a packaging decision.
The distinction between confirmed measures and proposed reforms is equally important.
The government’s planned exemption for qualifying hospitality glass packaging, its proposed recyclability discounts and the MPMA’s recommendations are at different stages of development.
They should not be treated as established changes with identical implications for every producer.
For companies operating internationally, differences between national EPR systems introduce another consideration.
Packaging fees, collection infrastructure and recycling arrangements vary between markets. A material that offers advantages in one country may not deliver the same results elsewhere.
This makes it important to evaluate packaging choices against the requirements of each market rather than relying on a single measure of environmental or commercial performance.
Balancing environmental goals with industrial competitiveness
The UK’s experience illustrates a wider challenge for countries introducing or expanding packaging EPR schemes.
Requiring producers to contribute to waste management costs can support recycling infrastructure and encourage improvements in packaging design.
However, the effectiveness of these systems depends on how charges are calculated, how costs are distributed and whether financial incentives encourage the intended behaviour.
The glass packaging reforms show that governments may need to adjust EPR rules when they create unintended costs.
The metal packaging industry’s response demonstrates why such changes also need to be assessed across competing materials and connected supply chains.
Environmental regulation, trade policy and industrial strategy can all influence packaging decisions. Their combined effects may be more significant than any individual measure.
For policymakers, the priority is to develop charging systems that are transparent, proportionate and supported by evidence.
For manufacturers, the challenge is to make packaging decisions that balance regulatory costs with product performance, environmental impact and supply chain requirements.
Ultimately, the long-term success of packaging EPR will depend on whether it improves waste management and recycling without creating avoidable barriers to manufacturing investment and competitiveness.