Barrier packaging helps protect products from environmental exposure during storage and distribution. However, selecting the material with the strongest possible barrier is not always the best solution.
Excessive barrier performance can add cost, material complexity and recycling challenges without delivering meaningful improvements in product protection.
Discover B2B Marketing That Performs
Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.
A crisp snack, an aroma-sensitive coffee product and a moisture-sensitive medicine all have different packaging requirements. Some products also need to retain moisture or allow gases to pass through their packaging rather than block them entirely.
For packaging manufacturers, converters and brand owners, the challenge is to identify which risks matter, establish how much protection is needed and ensure the finished package maintains that performance throughout its intended life.
What does the product need protection against?
Barrier packaging controls the movement of gases, water vapour and, in some applications, volatile compounds through packaging materials.
The first step in selecting a suitable structure is to identify what could cause the product to deteriorate.
Oxygen exposure can trigger oxidation, affecting flavour, colour, nutritional quality or the stability of sensitive ingredients.
Moisture presents different challenges. Water vapour entering a package can soften dry foods, cause powders to cake or affect moisture-sensitive pharmaceutical products. Conversely, some fresh foods require packaging that limits moisture loss.
Light can degrade sensitive ingredients, while aromas and other volatile compounds may escape through packaging or transfer between the product and its surroundings.
These risks vary considerably between products. Coffee, for example, may require both oxygen protection and aroma retention, while a dry snack may depend heavily on moisture resistance to maintain its crispness.
Packaging teams should identify the product’s critical quality attributes, acceptable deterioration limits and intended shelf life before specifying barrier requirements.
They should also establish whether the package needs to retain a modified atmosphere or allow controlled gas exchange, as may be necessary for fresh produce.
How much barrier protection is required?
Two common measurements help packaging engineers compare materials: oxygen transmission rate (OTR) and water vapour transmission rate (WVTR).
OTR measures how much oxygen passes through a material over a specified area and period under defined test conditions. WVTR measures the transmission of water vapour.
Lower values generally indicate greater resistance to oxygen or moisture transmission.
However, these figures do not tell the whole story.
Results depend on factors including temperature, humidity, material thickness, pressure differences and the testing method used. Materials should therefore be compared using equivalent conditions and measurement units.
Humidity is particularly important for certain barrier polymers.
Ethylene vinyl alcohol (EVOH), for example, can provide strong oxygen-barrier performance, but moisture absorption can reduce its effectiveness.
The required level of protection should be determined by the product’s sensitivity to oxygen or moisture, the size and design of the package, its headspace, expected storage conditions and intended shelf life.
Product testing and suitable modelling can help translate these requirements into meaningful material specifications.
Which barrier materials should manufacturers consider?
Packaging materials offer different combinations of protection, mechanical strength, flexibility, processing performance and cost.
Polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP) provide useful moisture resistance in many applications, although their oxygen-barrier performance may be insufficient for particularly sensitive products.
Polyethylene terephthalate (PET) combines mechanical strength and clarity with useful barrier properties. However, additional protection may be needed for applications with demanding oxygen-barrier requirements.
EVOH is commonly incorporated into multilayer structures to improve oxygen resistance, with other materials providing mechanical support, moisture protection or sealing functions.
Aluminium foil offers an excellent barrier against gases, moisture and light when intact. Its performance can nevertheless be compromised by pinholes, flex cracking or damage during converting and handling.
Metallised films and specialist barrier coatings provide alternative approaches, although their effectiveness depends on coating quality, material construction and mechanical durability.
Glass and metal containers can provide highly effective barriers through their walls. Closures, seams and other interfaces, however, remain potential pathways for leakage.
Paper and paperboard generally require coatings, liners or other treatments when substantial resistance to moisture, grease or gases is needed.
Material selection should consider the complete packaging structure, including thickness, closures and manufacturing requirements, rather than relying solely on the published properties of individual layers.
When is multilayer barrier packaging necessary?
Multilayer packaging combines materials to deliver functions that a single substrate may not provide.
A flexible packaging structure, for example, may use different layers for printability, mechanical strength, oxygen protection and heat sealing.
This approach can provide effective product protection, but additional layers can also increase cost, converting complexity and end-of-life challenges.
Adhesive compatibility, interlayer bonding and resistance to repeated flexing are important considerations.
Delamination or cracking can compromise the packaging structure, even when the individual materials have suitable barrier properties.
Manufacturers should therefore examine the purpose of each layer and assess whether a simpler construction could provide equivalent protection.
Possible approaches include removing unnecessary layers, optimising material thickness, using compatible barrier coatings or evaluating alternative material combinations.
However, simplification must be supported by testing. A thinner or less complex structure offers little benefit if it increases product damage, leakage or shelf-life failures.
How can barrier performance be maintained during production?
Even a high-performance barrier material cannot protect a product if the finished package is damaged or improperly sealed.
Weak seals, pinholes, cracks and faulty closures can create pathways for oxygen or moisture to enter, bypassing the material’s intended barrier protection.
For heat-sealed flexible packaging, seal quality depends on factors including temperature, pressure, dwell time, sealant compatibility and contamination in the sealing area.
These variables must be controlled within operating conditions established for the materials and equipment.
Package geometry can also affect performance. Sharp folds, corners and repeated flexing may damage certain barrier coatings or foil layers.
In rigid packaging, closure design, liner selection, container finish and capping conditions can influence package integrity.
Manufacturers should therefore evaluate the completed package alongside the barrier properties of its constituent materials.
Relevant assessments may include seal-strength testing, leak detection, package-integrity checks and mechanical or distribution testing.
These methods serve different purposes. A strong seal does not necessarily mean a package is leak-tight, while a low material transmission rate does not guarantee that the finished pack is free from leaks.
Why is shelf-life testing essential?
Shelf-life testing provides evidence that a packaging solution can protect the actual product under expected storage and distribution conditions.
Testing should focus on the quality attributes most likely to deteriorate, including moisture content, flavour, texture, colour, oxidation or active ingredient stability.
The appropriate measurements depend on the product and its particular failure mechanisms.
Real-time testing under representative conditions provides valuable evidence of packaging performance.
Accelerated testing can help compare materials and designs more quickly, but results require careful interpretation. Higher temperatures or humidity levels may change how a product deteriorates rather than simply accelerate the same process.
Modified-atmosphere packaging introduces additional considerations, including the initial gas composition, residual oxygen, package permeability and seal integrity.
Fresh produce may continue to respire after packing, making gas exchange particularly important. An excessively restrictive barrier can create unsuitable conditions inside the package.
Changes to materials, thickness or package construction should therefore prompt a review of existing shelf-life evidence.
Supplier data can support material selection, but it should not replace testing of the finished package with the intended product.
Can barrier packaging balance protection and recyclability?
Barrier performance and recyclability can create competing design requirements, particularly when packaging combines materials that are difficult to separate or recycle together.
However, recyclability cannot be determined simply by counting material layers or describing a package as mono-material.
Coatings, additives, inks, adhesives and other components can affect how packaging behaves during sorting and recycling.
The collection, sorting and recycling infrastructure available in the intended market is also important.
Material reduction presents a similar challenge.
A package that uses less material but allows more product to deteriorate may deliver a poorer overall environmental outcome when the consequences of product waste are considered.
Packaging teams should therefore compare options using a consistent assessment of product protection, material consumption, manufacturing performance, cost and realistic end-of-life pathways.
Any environmental claims should reflect the complete packaging construction and the recycling conditions in the markets where the product will be sold.
Choose barrier packaging based on proven performance
The right barrier packaging is the structure that provides sufficient protection throughout the product’s intended life under realistic manufacturing, storage and distribution conditions.
Selection should begin with identifying the main causes of product deterioration and defining the required shelf life.
Manufacturers can then compare materials and structures according to their barrier properties, sealing performance, mechanical durability, processing requirements, cost and end-of-life compatibility.
Testing the completed package with the actual product is essential, particularly when introducing new materials, reducing thickness or simplifying multilayer structures.
Ultimately, effective barrier packaging is not about achieving the lowest possible transmission rate. It is about providing the protection a product needs without unnecessary cost, complexity or material use.
