A package may look suitable on a design screen or perform well as an initial prototype, yet fail when exposed to filling machinery, warehouse stacking or transport conditions.
Weak seals, crushed cartons, leaking containers and damaged products can all result from problems overlooked during development. If these faults emerge after commercial production begins, the consequences can include rejected batches, wasted materials, production delays and expensive redesigns.
Discover B2B Marketing That Performs
Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.
Pre-production testing helps packaging manufacturers, converters and brand owners assess whether a proposed design can protect its contents, run reliably on production equipment and withstand the conditions it will encounter during distribution.
The objective is not to carry out every available test. It is to identify the most likely causes of failure and select methods that provide meaningful evidence of performance before a design is approved.
Define what the packaging needs to achieve
Testing should begin with a clear understanding of what the package must do.
Requirements depend on the product, packaging format, intended shelf life and distribution conditions.
A corrugated carton carrying heavy goods may need to withstand stacking loads and repeated handling. A flexible pouch may require reliable seals and protection against oxygen or moisture. A rigid container may need sufficient impact resistance and a closure that prevents leakage.
Packaging teams should translate these requirements into measurable performance criteria before selecting test methods.
These may include mechanical strength, seal integrity, barrier properties, dimensional accuracy, compatibility with filling equipment and resistance to transport damage.
Product safety and regulatory requirements must also be considered, particularly for food, pharmaceutical and medical packaging.
Testing should assess the complete packaging system, including closures, cushioning, labels and secondary packaging, rather than treating individual materials in isolation.
Assess materials and structural strength
Material and structural testing helps establish whether packaging can withstand the forces encountered during manufacture, handling and distribution.
For corrugated packaging, compression testing measures resistance to stacking loads. Board properties, carton dimensions, construction and environmental conditions all influence how much weight a package can support.
Drop and impact testing can reveal weaknesses in packaging designed to protect products from handling shocks.
Flexible films may require tensile, tear or puncture testing, depending on the application. These assessments help establish whether materials are likely to stretch, split or become damaged during converting and use.
Rigid plastic containers may be tested for dimensional consistency, deformation and impact resistance under relevant conditions.
However, material strength alone does not establish the performance of a finished package.
A strong film can still fail at a seal, while a carton made from suitable board may collapse because of poor structural design.
Testing should therefore cover both the materials and the assembled packaging.
Verify seals, closures and package integrity
Seals and closures are critical because they help determine whether packaging can protect its contents throughout storage and distribution.
In flexible packaging, heat-seal performance depends on factors such as temperature, pressure, dwell time, sealant compatibility and contamination at the sealing interface.
Seal-strength testing measures the force required to separate a seal, while leak testing identifies pathways through which air, liquid or other substances may pass.
These methods assess different properties. A strong seal is not necessarily leak-tight, and a package that passes a leak test may still lack sufficient seal strength for handling and distribution.
For rigid containers, assessments may examine closure fit, sealing performance, torque retention and resistance to leakage.
The choice of method should reflect the product and packaging format.
A liquid container, for example, may require different integrity checks from a pouch designed to maintain a modified atmosphere or protect a moisture-sensitive product.
Manufacturers should also establish whether sealing performance remains consistent across the operating conditions expected during production.
Measure barrier performance and shelf life
Packaging designed to protect sensitive products may need to restrict exposure to oxygen, water vapour, light or other environmental factors.
Oxygen transmission rate (OTR) and water vapour transmission rate (WVTR) are commonly used to measure the barrier properties of packaging materials.
Lower transmission rates generally indicate greater resistance to oxygen or moisture transfer, although results depend on conditions such as temperature, humidity and material thickness.
However, material-level measurements do not prove that a finished package will provide the required protection.
Pinholes, damaged coatings, weak seals and faulty closures can create pathways through which oxygen or moisture enters.
Shelf-life studies help establish whether packaging maintains product quality over the required period.
Depending on the product, assessments may monitor moisture content, flavour, texture, colour, oxidation or the stability of sensitive ingredients.
Real-time testing under representative storage conditions provides valuable evidence.
Accelerated testing can support development, but results require careful interpretation because elevated temperatures or humidity may alter the mechanisms responsible for product deterioration.
Where possible, packaging teams should validate the proposed structure using the actual product rather than relying solely on material specifications.
Simulate transport and storage conditions
Packaging must protect products beyond the production facility.
During distribution, it may experience vibration, drops, compression, repeated handling and changes in temperature or humidity.
Transport simulation helps assess whether the complete packaging system can withstand these conditions.
Drop testing can expose weaknesses caused by impact, while vibration testing can reveal damage associated with repeated movement.
Compression testing can assess the ability of cartons and other packaging formats to resist stacking loads.
Environmental conditioning may also be necessary, particularly where moisture or temperature changes affect material strength and dimensional stability.
Test selection should reflect the intended distribution route.
A package moving through an e-commerce delivery network may face different handling conditions from one transported in palletised loads.
Procedures from organisations such as the International Safe Transit Association (ISTA) and ASTM International provide recognised frameworks for evaluating transport performance.
However, the selected procedure, test severity and acceptance criteria must match the product, package configuration and expected journey.
Test compatibility with production machinery
A package that performs well in laboratory tests may still cause problems on a production line.
Film stiffness, surface friction, carton dimensions, container geometry and closure design can all influence how packaging materials feed, form, fill and seal.
Pre-production machinery trials can identify problems such as poor feeding, misalignment, inconsistent sealing, container deformation and excessive start-up waste.
Trials should use representative materials, equipment settings and production speeds.
For flexible packaging, this may involve checking web handling, forming performance, sealing conditions and cutting accuracy.
Rigid packaging trials may focus on container handling, filling, capping, labelling and conveying.
Carton packaging may require checks of erecting, folding, adhesive application and case packing.
Manufacturers should record defects, interruptions and acceptable output during trials.
Simply establishing that a machine can run the packaging is not enough. A design that requires frequent adjustments or generates excessive rejects may be unsuitable for reliable commercial production.
Validate prototypes and pilot production runs
Testing is most effective when it takes place throughout packaging development rather than being left until final approval.
Early prototypes can help assess dimensions, structural design, product fit and handling requirements.
More representative samples can then undergo mechanical, barrier, seal and distribution testing.
Pilot production runs provide an opportunity to assess how materials, machinery, operators and process settings interact before full-scale manufacture begins.
However, results must be interpreted according to how closely test samples represent commercial packaging.
Hand-assembled prototypes, laboratory seals and small production batches may behave differently from packaging manufactured at normal line speeds.
Changes to materials, suppliers, tooling or manufacturing processes can also affect performance.
Packaging teams should therefore establish when additional testing is required and ensure final approval is based on sufficiently representative samples.
Set acceptance criteria and investigate failures
Test results are useful only when they can be compared with clearly defined requirements.
Before testing begins, manufacturers should establish what constitutes acceptable performance.
Criteria may include minimum seal strength, maximum allowable leakage, permitted deformation, acceptable levels of product damage or the ability to maintain specified quality attributes.
These limits should reflect the product’s requirements, applicable regulations and realistic conditions of use.
When a package fails, simply repeating the test is unlikely to resolve the underlying problem.
Packaging teams should investigate whether the cause lies in material selection, structural design, sealing conditions, closure performance or the test conditions themselves.
Any design or process changes should be followed by appropriate retesting.
Records should document sample construction, test methods, conditions, results and deviations from the agreed procedure.
This creates a basis for consistent approval decisions and helps prevent problems from recurring after production changes.
Approve packaging based on proven performance
Pre-production testing enables manufacturers to make packaging decisions based on evidence rather than assumptions.
The most effective programmes begin by identifying likely failure mechanisms and defining the performance requirements that matter to the product.
Material assessments, seal and integrity checks, shelf-life studies, transport simulation and machinery trials can then be selected according to those risks.
The objective is not to eliminate every conceivable risk through excessive testing. It is to establish sufficient confidence that the finished package will protect the product, perform reliably on the production line and withstand its intended distribution environment.
By identifying weaknesses before commercial production begins, manufacturers can reduce avoidable waste, prevent costly failures and approve packaging designs with greater confidence.
